GP Negligence: When Can You Claim Against Your Doctor?

Your GP owes you a duty of care at every consultation, from diagnosis and referral through to prescribing and monitoring. Here is when a failure to meet that standard becomes a clinical negligence claim and what you need to establish.

Terry Moran November 20, 2026

You can bring a clinical negligence claim against a GP where the care they provided fell below the standard of a reasonably competent general practitioner, and where that failure caused you harm that would not otherwise have occurred. GPs owe their patients a duty of care from the moment of any consultation, and that duty covers examination, diagnosis, investigation, referral, prescribing, and the ongoing management of long-term conditions.

What Does a GP Negligence Claim Require?

Every GP negligence claim must establish three things: that the GP owed the patient a duty of care, that the care provided fell below the required standard, and that the failure caused the harm suffered.

The duty of care is not in dispute in any case involving a registered patient and their GP practice. The contested elements in almost all GP negligence claims are breach of duty and causation.

The standard of care: Bolam and Bolitho

The standard against which a GP’s conduct is assessed is that of a reasonably competent general practitioner, not a specialist. A GP is not expected to have the specialist knowledge of a consultant cardiologist or oncologist. They are, however, expected to recognise when a patient’s presentation warrants investigation or referral to a specialist, to make sound diagnostic decisions within the scope of their training, to prescribe safely and appropriately, and to manage the ongoing care of patients with long-term conditions in accordance with current evidence and national guidance.

The Bolam test, established in Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582, provides that a clinician is not negligent if their conduct accords with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion in the relevant field. The House of Lords confirmed in Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232 that any such body of opinion must be capable of withstanding logical analysis. In practice, this means that a GP who departs from NICE guidance without documented clinical justification, or who fails to investigate or refer a presentation that clearly warranted it, cannot shelter behind the bare fact that some other GPs might have made the same decision.

Causation: what difference did the failure make?

Establishing causation in GP negligence claims requires the claimant to show on the balance of probabilities that the failure caused or materially contributed to the harm suffered. In delayed diagnosis cases, this typically requires expert evidence on what would have happened if the correct assessment, investigation, or referral had been made at the time it should have been: what the clinical picture would have been, what treatment would have been available, and whether the outcome would have been materially better.

The Most Common Forms of GP Negligence

Failure to refer for suspected cancer

NICE guideline NG12, Suspected Cancer: Recognition and Referral, most recently updated in January 2026, sets out the symptoms that should trigger an urgent suspected cancer pathway referral in primary care across more than twenty cancer types. The guideline uses a threshold of a 3 per cent positive predictive value, meaning that any symptom or combination of symptoms carrying at least a 3 per cent risk of cancer in the relevant population warrants a clinical response.

A failure by a GP to refer a patient whose presentation meets the NG12 threshold is a departure from national guidance that is very difficult to defend. The most commonly litigated failures in this area include attributing rectal bleeding to haemorrhoids without appropriate investigation, dismissing persistent cough in a patient with risk factors for lung cancer, failing to arrange CA125 testing and ultrasound for a patient with persistent bloating and pelvic pain, and failing to refer a breast lump meeting the referral criteria.

The causation analysis in cancer delay cases is addressed in detail in the companion article on cancer misdiagnosis claims. In summary, a claim is strongest where the cancer was at an early and highly curable stage at the time of the missed referral and had advanced significantly by the time it was diagnosed, since the claimant can then show that earlier referral would more probably than not have led to a better outcome.

Failure to diagnose a serious acute condition

GPs are often the first clinical contact for patients presenting with the early signs of serious and time-critical conditions. A failure to consider and investigate these conditions, or to refer urgently when they are suspected, can result in catastrophic harm.

Common examples include:

  • Failure to consider meningitis in a patient with fever, headache, neck stiffness, or photophobia, or to advise immediate emergency department attendance
  • Failure to recognise the symptoms of stroke and to call for emergency services
  • Failure to identify the signs of sepsis and to arrange urgent hospital assessment
  • Failure to investigate chest pain appropriately, including failure to perform or arrange an urgent ECG
  • Failure to consider ectopic pregnancy in a woman of reproductive age presenting with abdominal pain

In each of these cases, the causation analysis focuses on the window of time lost by the GP’s failure to act, and what different management within that window would have achieved for the patient.

Delayed diagnosis of serious long-term conditions

Many serious conditions develop gradually and may present to a GP over multiple consultations before a diagnosis is reached. Where a GP repeatedly attributes symptoms to a benign cause without adequate investigation, or fails to take a symptom pattern seriously over an extended period, the resulting delay in diagnosis can cause significant harm. Common conditions giving rise to this type of claim include type 1 diabetes presenting as diabetic ketoacidosis, inflammatory conditions including rheumatoid arthritis and inflammatory bowel disease, and neurological conditions including multiple sclerosis where early symptoms were not followed up.

Prescription and medication errors

GPs prescribe a very large volume of medication, and errors in prescribing can cause serious harm. Commonly litigated failures include prescribing a medication to a patient with a documented allergy or contraindication, prescribing an incorrect dose with harmful consequences, failing to warn a patient adequately of significant side effects or interactions, and failing to monitor a patient on medication that requires regular review, such as anticoagulants, lithium, or methotrexate. Where a medication error causes direct physical harm, the connection between the prescribing failure and the injury is usually relatively direct.

Failure to act on investigation results

A GP who requests an investigation takes on a responsibility to review the result and to act on it appropriately. A failure to chase up an unreturned result, a failure to review and act on an abnormal result, or a failure to communicate a significant finding to the patient in a timely way are all recognised bases for a GP negligence claim. These cases often involve a result that was received by the practice and filed without action, only coming to light when the patient presents months or years later with a more advanced condition that the result should have prompted earlier investigation of.

Failure to refer to an appropriate specialist

A GP is a generalist whose role includes recognising when a patient’s condition requires assessment or management by a specialist, and making an appropriate referral in a timely way. A failure to refer where referral was indicated, an unduly delayed referral, or a referral to the wrong specialty given the clinical picture, can each constitute negligence where the patient suffers harm as a result. The applicable standard is whether a reasonably competent GP in the same circumstances should have recognised the need for referral and acted on it.

Safety-netting failures

A GP who assesses a patient and decides that the clinical picture does not yet require referral or investigation takes on an obligation to provide the patient with clear information about what symptoms should prompt them to return, and how urgently. A failure to provide this safety-netting advice, or safety-netting advice that was so vague as to be useless, can form the basis of a claim where the patient subsequently suffers harm that earlier return and reassessment would have prevented.

Telephone and online consultation failures

The shift toward remote consulting has introduced particular risks in primary care. A telephone or online consultation conducted without the ability to examine the patient, observe their appearance, or assess their vital signs relies entirely on what the patient reports. Where a GP conducting a remote consultation fails to identify red flag features in a patient’s history, fails to recognise that the clinical picture requires an in-person examination, or provides reassurance on the basis of inadequate information, the resulting failure may be assessed against the standard of a GP who should have arranged to see the patient in person rather than managing them remotely.

Consent in the GP Setting

The Supreme Court’s decision in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11 applies to all clinical decisions in general practice, not only to surgical procedures. A GP recommending a course of treatment, a medication, or an investigation is required to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks and of any reasonable alternatives. A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient’s position would be likely to attach significance to it.

In the GP context, the Montgomery standard is most commonly relevant to decisions about medication, where the patient should be informed of significant side effects and interactions; to referral decisions, where the patient may have options about the type of specialist they see or the urgency of the referral; and to any procedure carried out in the GP setting, including minor surgical procedures, joint injections, and coil fittings.

Who Is Liable: The GP, the Practice, or the NHS?

Most GPs in England and Wales work as independent contractors operating under a General Medical Services or Personal Medical Services contract with their NHS integrated care board. Unlike hospital clinicians, who are employed by an NHS trust, most GPs are not NHS employees. This means that the vicarious liability mechanism that applies straightforwardly in hospital claims requires a slightly different analysis in the GP context.

In practice, where a GP causes harm through their own negligence, the claim is typically brought against the GP practice as a partnership or limited liability partnership, which is liable for the acts of its partners and employed staff. Where the negligent GP was a locum, the position may be more complex, since liability may lie with the locum personally, with the practice that booked them, or with the agency that supplied them, depending on the specific contractual arrangements. A specialist solicitor will identify the correct defendant as part of the initial assessment of the claim.

NHS Resolution provides indemnity support to GPs through the Clinical Negligence Scheme for General Practice, so the practical experience of pursuing a GP claim is broadly similar to pursuing a hospital trust claim from the claimant’s perspective.

What Compensation Can You Claim?

Compensation in a GP negligence claim follows the same structure as any clinical negligence case.

General damages compensate for the pain, suffering, and loss of amenity caused by the harm that resulted from the GP’s failure. In cancer delay cases this may include the experience of more aggressive treatment and a worsened prognosis. In prescription error cases it may include the physical and psychological consequences of a medication reaction. In cases involving a missed acute diagnosis, it may include the consequences of a stroke, sepsis, or other serious condition that was not treated in time.

Special damages cover financial losses including lost earnings, private medical treatment costs, care provided by family members, and other out-of-pocket expenses attributable to the failure. Future losses are relevant where the harm has produced permanent or long-lasting consequences.

Time Limits

The standard three-year limitation period under the Limitation Act 1980 applies, running from the date of the negligent consultation or from the date of knowledge that the harm may have been caused by a failure in GP care. In cases involving delayed diagnosis, the date of knowledge will often be later than the date of the original consultation, since the patient may not have known that something went wrong until they received a different diagnosis or sought independent medical advice. Legal advice should be sought promptly once a potential GP failure is identified.

What to Do Next

If you believe your GP failed to meet the required standard and caused you avoidable harm, the following steps apply:

  1. Request your full GP records. You are entitled to these under the Data Protection Act 2018, and your solicitor can request them on your behalf. The records will show the full history of your presentations and the clinical decisions made at each point.
  2. Seek specialist legal advice. A clinical negligence solicitor will review the records and advise on whether the clinical management appears to have fallen below the required standard.
  3. Independent expert evidence is commissioned. A GP expert will provide an opinion on whether the care met the required standard and, together with a specialist in the relevant clinical area, will address the causation question.
  4. A letter of claim is sent. Once the evidence supports a claim, this is sent under the Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes.

Talk to Satchell Moran Solicitors

A failure by a GP to diagnose or refer a serious condition can have consequences that last a lifetime. At Satchell Moran Solicitors, our specialist clinical negligence team handles GP negligence claims across the full range of failures described in this article, and we act on a no win, no fee basis so there is no financial barrier to finding out whether you have a claim. As a dual Lexcel accredited firm, we are committed to the highest standards of client care throughout.

If you believe your GP failed to provide the standard of care you were entitled to, contact us today for an initial, confidential and no obligation conversation.

Start your claim

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

 Possibly, if the clinical picture at the time warranted a different approach including specialist review. The relevant question is not whether a second opinion would have been helpful in hindsight, but whether a reasonably competent GP should have recognised at the time that the patient’s presentation required specialist assessment. Where that threshold was met and referral did not happen, a claim may be available.

 A GP conducting a remote consultation is still required to meet the standard of a reasonably competent GP. If the clinical picture required in-person examination and the GP failed to identify this and arrange it, that failure may itself constitute negligence. The standard is not reduced simply because the consultation was remote.

Yes, provided the delay resulted from a failure in the standard of care rather than from the inherent difficulty of the condition. Where a GP repeatedly attributed symptoms to a benign cause over a prolonged period without appropriate investigation or referral, and where earlier correct management would have produced a materially better outcome, a claim may succeed. The date of knowledge provision under the Limitation Act 1980 means the three-year clock for the claim will generally run from when you became aware that the delay may have been caused by a clinical failure, not from the date of the original consultations.

Yes in most cases. Where a GP was participating in the Clinical Negligence Scheme for General Practice at the time of the relevant care, NHS Resolution retains liability for claims arising from that period regardless of subsequent changes to the practice structure. Your solicitor will identify the correct route for your specific circumstances.

A referral to the wrong specialty can constitute negligence if a reasonably competent GP should have identified that a different specialist was required given the clinical picture. The causation question focuses on whether a correct referral would have led to an earlier or better outcome than the one actually achieved.

Yes, the GP or practice will be notified as part of the formal pre-action process. Making a legitimate clinical negligence claim does not affect your right to remain a patient at the practice, and a GP cannot lawfully remove a patient from their list solely because a claim has been made.

View More Articles
GP Negligence: When Can You Claim Against Your Doctor?