Fixed costs reform is one of the most significant changes to civil litigation in England and Wales in recent years, and housing disrepair claimants need to understand what it means for how claims are funded, what solicitors can recover, and how it affects the no win no fee model that most tenants rely on. The reforms, which extended the fixed recoverable costs regime to most civil claims with a value up to 100,000 pounds from 1 October 2023, have changed the economics of bringing a housing disrepair claim in ways that are worth understanding before you instruct a solicitor.
When a civil claim succeeds, the losing party, typically the landlord in a housing disrepair case, is usually ordered to pay a contribution towards the winning party’s legal costs. Before the October 2023 reforms, the amount recoverable in most cases was assessed by the court on a detailed basis, taking into account the work done and the rates charged. This process was slow, expensive, and unpredictable.
Fixed recoverable costs, known as FRC, replace that assessment with a predetermined schedule of costs recoverable at each stage of the litigation, depending on the value and complexity of the claim. The amount a winning claimant’s solicitor can recover from the losing landlord is now set by the rules rather than assessed case by case.
The October 2023 reforms, introduced by Sir Geoffrey Vos, the Master of the Rolls, as part of a broader civil justice review, extended FRC to most claims allocated to the fast track (claims with a value broadly between 10,000 and 25,000 pounds) and introduced a new intermediate track for claims valued between 25,000 and 100,000 pounds, with its own FRC regime. Claims above 100,000 pounds remain on the multi-track, where costs are still assessed rather than fixed.
Most housing disrepair claims fall within the value range affected by the reforms. A straightforward disrepair claim involving damp and mould over a period of two to three years, with a general damages award and modest special damages, will typically have a total value within the fast track or intermediate track range. This means the costs recoverable from the landlord if the claim succeeds are now governed by the FRC schedule rather than assessed.
The practical effect is that the fixed costs recoverable from a losing landlord are, in many cases, lower than the costs a solicitor acting diligently on the claim will actually incur. The gap between what the solicitor charges and what is recovered from the other side is the shortfall that the fee structure in the conditional fee agreement must address, typically through the success fee payable from the claimant’s compensation if the claim succeeds.
This dynamic is not new: costs recovery from the other side has never fully covered the cost of running a claim on a no win no fee basis. But the introduction of fixed costs has made the shortfall more predictable, if not smaller, and has placed greater emphasis on the success fee as the mechanism by which the solicitor recovers the cost of the risk they take.
The success fee in a housing disrepair conditional fee agreement is the percentage of compensation the solicitor deducts if the claim succeeds. It compensates the solicitor for the financial risk of running cases where they may recover nothing if the claim fails, and for the shortfall between fixed recoverable costs and the actual cost of the work.
Under the fixed costs regime, the economics of housing disrepair claims have tightened. Solicitors operating in this area need to manage their costs carefully against the fixed amounts recoverable from the other side, which means the success fee becomes more significant as a component of the overall funding model.
This is directly relevant to tenants. The success fee percentage agreed at the outset of a claim determines how much of your compensation you keep. In a market where fixed recoverable costs have reduced what solicitors can recover from landlords, some firms have responded by maintaining or increasing success fee percentages to compensate. A firm charging a 25% success fee is taking a quarter of your compensation on top of the costs recovered from the landlord. A firm charging 50% is taking half.
Understanding what success fee you are being asked to agree to, and how it compares to the market, is therefore more important under the fixed costs regime than it was before.
The FRC regime is not entirely rigid. For cases of particular complexity, the rules provide for a complexity uplift of up to 50% on the standard fixed costs figures in certain circumstances. Whether a housing disrepair case qualifies for an uplift depends on the specific factors involved, such as the number of defendants, the complexity of the expert evidence, or the involvement of a significant personal injury element.
Claims above 100,000 pounds, which covers cases involving serious personal injury with high general damages awards, remain outside the FRC regime entirely and are assessed on the multi-track. Where a housing disrepair case involves severe and prolonged health consequences with substantial medical evidence, the total value may exceed the intermediate track threshold, taking it outside the fixed costs rules. A solicitor will advise on which track is likely to apply to your claim based on the estimated value once the evidence is reviewed.
Fixed costs reform changes how much a solicitor can recover from the losing party. It does not change the underlying legal rights of tenants, the obligations of social and private landlords, the pre-action protocol process, or the basis on which compensation is assessed. A tenant with a strong housing disrepair claim has the same legal entitlement to compensation as they had before October 2023. What has changed is the financial structure of how that entitlement is pursued and funded.
The reforms also do not affect Awaab’s Law obligations, which apply to social landlords independently of the civil costs regime. A social landlord who fails to investigate damp or mould within the required 10-working-day period is in breach of those obligations regardless of how costs are recovered in any subsequent civil claim.
Fixed costs reform makes it more important than ever to understand the financial terms of your conditional fee agreement before you sign it. The following are the key questions to ask.
What is the success fee percentage? This is the percentage of your compensation the solicitor will deduct if the claim succeeds. Under the fixed costs regime, this is the primary mechanism by which the solicitor recovers the shortfall between fixed recoverable costs and the actual cost of running your case.
Are disbursements covered? Disbursements such as the surveyor’s report, medical records, and court fees are not covered by the success fee. Ask whether your agreement includes after the event insurance to cover disbursements if the claim fails, or whether you may be liable for these costs in a losing case.
What is the basis for the fixed costs recovery? Ask your solicitor to explain which track they expect your claim to be allocated to, what the fixed costs recoverable at each stage are, and how they affect the overall fee structure.
Is there a cap on the success fee deduction? Some agreements cap the total deduction from your compensation, providing certainty about the minimum amount you will receive if the claim succeeds.
You can read more about how the success fee works in housing disrepair claims in our no win no fee housing disrepair guide, and about how compensation is calculated in our housing disrepair compensation guide.
If you are a council or housing association tenant with unresolved disrepair:
You can find out more about the claims process on our housing disrepair claims page.
Satchell Moran Solicitors acts for tenants across England and Wales in housing disrepair claims on a no win no fee basis, with dual Lexcel accreditation and transparent funding terms. We are clear about the success fee and disbursement arrangements from the outset, so you know exactly what you will keep if your claim succeeds. Get in touch today for a free initial enquiry with no obligation to proceed.
Start your claimThe reforms changed the financial structure of claims rather than the legal basis for bringing them. Tenant rights and landlord obligations are unchanged. The practical effect is that solicitors must manage their costs more carefully against fixed recoverable amounts, which makes the choice of solicitor and the terms of the conditional fee agreement more important than before.
Fixed costs affect what your solicitor can recover from the landlord in costs, not the amount of compensation awarded to you. However, where fixed recoverable costs fall short of the solicitor’s actual costs, the success fee deducted from your compensation is the mechanism by which that shortfall is addressed. A lower success fee means you keep more of your compensation.
The October 2023 FRC reforms apply to claims allocated to the fast track (broadly up to 25,000 pounds) and the new intermediate track (up to 100,000 pounds). Claims above 100,000 pounds remain on the multi-track with costs assessed rather than fixed. Most straightforward housing disrepair claims fall within the affected range, though cases with significant personal injury elements may exceed the intermediate track threshold.
After the event insurance, known as ATE insurance, is a policy taken out after a dispute arises, designed to cover costs such as the other side’s legal fees or disbursements if the claim is unsuccessful. Under the fixed costs regime, ATE insurance is less commonly required in housing disrepair claims than in higher-value litigation, but it may still be relevant where significant disbursements are involved. Ask your solicitor whether ATE insurance is part of your funding arrangement and what it covers.
Yes. The fixed costs regime applies to claims across the value range, including lower-value claims. The economics of smaller claims are tighter for solicitors under fixed costs, which is one reason why some firms focus on cases with a clear structural cause and good evidence. A specialist housing disrepair solicitor will assess the merits of your case on its specific facts.
The reforms have generally been associated with greater predictability in costs rather than a change in settlement timescales. Most housing disrepair claims continue to resolve through negotiation under the pre-action protocol rather than at trial, and the protocol timeline remains broadly the same as before the reforms.